Commentary

Freud's 180º

Did Freud come up with the infantile sexuality theory because he was too afraid to see what was repressed within him?

10 min read

Without a doubt, I have an obsessive mind.

Every now and then, a specific subject intrigues me that I then proceed to chase down. It brings me great peace when I resolve these kinks in my mindspace. I could access peace without chasing down any of these kinks, but I do enjoy the adventure of chasing down obscure topics.

A couple of years ago, I started wondering how Freud came up with the Oedipus and Elektra complexes–the idea that infants inherently held sexual desire towards the parent of the opposite sex, sometimes also referred to as the theory of infantile sexuality.

Ever since I learnt about the complexes, I had been fascinated with the concept. Having been a mama's boy through most of my life, the Oedipus concept presented to me the shadow of what it means to see one's mother as free of any blemishes–the latent desire to f*** the mother and kill the father.

Myths can be quite sinister. I think that contributes to their longevity. A myth is a story that survives. It lives on because it manages to reflect an extreme version of what a large group of humans experience but struggle to speak about.

In reflecting sinisterly what is present in humans, myths cut straight to the heart of the collective shadow.

By presenting the most terrible form of the thing you are struggling to look at myths relax your struggle to better see and accept yourself.

Maybe it isn't that bad that sometimes I get quite angry with my father for how he treats my mother. Compared to wanting to f*** your mother and kill your father, yeah it isn't that bad.

Enough space to contemplate the nature of the attachment a mama's boy has to his mother. What aspects are healthy? What are unhealthy? Where should he step in between the marriage of his parents? Where it's best for him to let their dynamic play out the way it is meant to?

As I began to recover repressed memories of child sex abuse, there was a season where I wondered how my mother contributed to it.

How could it be that she missed her father's regular abusage of her son? She seems to have caught onto certain themes.

She could tell that my eating habits had changed and worked very hard to "make me lose weight".

She could tell that at some point, I had stopped confiding in her about what happened in my life on a day to day basis.

She was attuned enough to track the symptoms but not unlike most of the medical system, too busy to track the root causes.

At some point, I wondered if she willfully turned her eyes away because she was directly complicit. Not in partnership with my grandfather but still independently sexually abusing me.

Now, this was a season where my obsessive mind had latched onto the grand project of recovering all repressed memories, considering it as necessary for healing. So it darted in a variety of directions.

It is so intimate the relationship between a child and mother. Categorically speaking, a mother and child engage in physical acts that are only otherwise replicated in romantic contexts.

Suckling on a teat. Emerging out from between the thighs.

At a sharing circle in an ISTA training, a single mother had expressed how confused she'd be when she'd experience arousal while breastfeeding her child. How would you feel if you have not had intimate touch in the most tender, vulnerable chapter of your life and then needed to have an innocent, hungry being suckle on your breasts stirring past memories of not-so-innocent hungry beings doing the same?

Innately, the Oedipus Complex made some sense to me. But then as I started processing my repressed sexual trauma, I reconsidered it and certain aspects of its presentation started–like how the young 'uns say these days–giving me the ick.

Correspondingly, I had also tapped into the pure rage that I had held suppressed towards my mother. When I first discovered it, I was shocked to say the least. But looking back, it makes sense. It balanced out the part of me that saw her as the most pure, most innocent being. The Madonna/Whore complex playing out within my psyche. (Yes, this essay is going to critique Freud, but boy, did the man come up with some catchy ideas!)

Rage obfuscates truth. While still filled with rage, before I received the  freeing cleansing of it via the grace offered freely by the overflowing blood of Jesus crucified on the cross and maintaining a spirit of forgiveness towards his tormentors, I couldn't tell if my mom was:

  1. ignorant of my sexual abuse from my grandfather because of her own repressed trauma
  2. knew of it but was too afraid to speak up and filled with shame to admit it as I confronted her now
  3. unaware of it but also contributed independently to my sexual abuse because she did not know the difference between good touch and bad touch
  4. unaware/aware and willfully partook in the abuse

'Tis was a season of my healing journey where I was obsessed with recovering all the repressed memories.

Over time I learnt that the nature of bodily trauma is such that it can get activated in scenarios where the body is taking the shape that it took while the abuse was happening. And if an innocent bystander is not attuned to the activated trauma and so, fails to bring sufficient sensitivity to it, then the victim's mind ends up projecting the perpetrator onto the bystander. This is how trauma entanglements happen. They often happen in romantic relationships. Once entangled thusly, couples may find it very difficult to resolve the crux of the issues unless they get to the root of the entanglement. It is quite heartbreaking when couples stay stuck in surface level arguments when the root cause is something else really.

You don't have to be romantically involved for such an entanglement to happen.

During this same season, I also wondered if my childhood dentist had fellated me as a child.

A segue.

You know, it's quite vulnerable to share this openly because a part of me fears that those who seem convinced that I'm making all of this up, will use this as fodder for their cause.

It has always astonished me when I encounter people–in my family or outside–who are more confident about the invalidity of my recovered memories than I am about their validity. Buddy, how can you be more sure about what did not happen in my childhood than me? Were you with me 24/7?

Over time, I have concluded that encountering a human speaking about recovery of repressed trauma can be a very scary experience for folks with deeply repressed trauma, and sometimes they can fight back by trying to invalidate the mirror in front of them. I have learnt that it's best to meet such situations with loving boundaries.

"Hey, it seems like you have full certainty that what I'm sharing with you is untrue. That doesn't align with the level of certainty I'm at. And that's fine. We can agree to disagree on this and why don't we get to know each other on different, less charged topics?"

Or a stronger variant–

"Hey, you are speaking with much dismissive certainty on subjects that you possibly couldn't have complete information on. So don't do that, please. Yeah?"

Back to the dentist.

Holding my mouth open uncomfortably in the dentist's chair was the shape that resembled being fellated by my grandfather.

A visit to the dentist then became a childhood experience where that trauma got activated, and my body stored the memory of being in the dentist's chair in a similar place as where it stored memories of the old man forcing blowjobs out of me.

Over time, the wonderings with regards to my mother and the dentist whittled out while the somatic memories of fellatio and sodomy from my grandfather and his friend stayed.

I struggle to verbalize this distinction. But I experienced a distinct difference between the somatic memories and trauma wonderings–the latter seem to emerge in the head but never make it to a steady place in the body. The former emerged vividly from the body and caused a persistent struggle of acceptance in my mind.

Anywho, this was the context under which I decided to explore how Freud came up with the Oedipus and Elektra complexes–the idea that infants innately have sexual desire for the parent of the opposite sex.

Did you know that the primary source of Freud's methodology of Psychoanalysis is the correspondence between him and a close confidant–Wilhelm Fliess–from 1887-1904?

While in Vienna, Freud treated a lot of women that showed symptoms that he clubbed under the label hysteria. Many of these women had confided  to Freud, while in hysteric bouts, that they had experienced sexual abuse from their fathers.

Correspondingly, Freud had developed the seduction theory that claimed that repressed memories of child sex abuse in early childhood was the essential precondition for hysteria.

The reports, however, began to stack up. They got so numerous that Freud wrote a letter in September of 1897 to Wilhelm.

He looked at the numerous nature of the reports and deduced that in order for his theory to hold, the incidence of child sex abuse had to be quite widespread. Then, he intuits that surely, such instances can't be so widespread. Surely, not in middle class Vienna! So many upstanding men can't be perverts! Of course not!

Intriguingly, in that same line he suspects his own father of such perversions.

There is another letter of note here. On February 11, 1897, Freud suspects that his father's perversions are responsible for the hysteria of his brother and sisters.

Screenshot from the Internet Archive. Interestingly, this section was left out of the first release of his private correspondence in German, by his daughter, Anna Freud. It was later included in the English release by Jeffrey Masson who then wrote a book called The Assault on Truth that argued that Freud abandoned the seduction theory to protect his career. Masson was thoroughly ostracized by the psychoanalytic community.

This begs the question: Frau Freud, when you suspected your father of having acted perversely towards your siblings while also being aware that trauma can get repressed, how did it not cross your mind that you might have repressed similar trauma from your own father?

Does that not follow deductively? Perhaps your deductive reasoning stymied itself in face of such horror?

In a span of a few months, where he wrote about his father's perversions towards his siblings and wondered out loud about the high incidence of child sex abuse in Vienna, Freud did a 180 on his theories.

The seduction theory was chucked out in favor of the theory of infantile sexuality–that infants harbor innate sexual desires towards the parent of the opposite sex (Oedipus & Elektra complexes) and that hysteria resulted from the unresolved conflicts emerging from these complexes.

Freud's turnaround had a significant impact on how western psychology handled child sex abuse.

Bessel van der Kolk writes in The Body Keeps the Score-

Now is it possible that in all cases where a client reports a repressed memory of childhood sexual abuse, what is really happening is that the client's unprocessed infantile sexuality complex has warped itself into entanglements with different adults, thereby leading to the client's mind developing fantastic ideas of being sexually abused? I suppose one could hold that as a hypothesis and attempt to treat clients and help them overcome hysteria and let the results speak for themselves? And for that, the theory and the complexes would have to expand from the object being just the parent of the opposite sex to a wide range of adults of either sex–who victims name as being sexually abused by.

I don't know. Seems a bit implausible to me. Is it possible that in some cases the victim names the wrong perpetrator? Yes, I experienced that for sure. Is it possible that no one actually sexually abused me and that all the people I have named are wrong, born out of a hysteric episode due to my unprocessed Oedipus complex?

Sure, it's a hypothesis I could hold. We would need more exploration to conclude whether that hypothesis is accurate. It's only prudent that I also explore the background of such a strong hypothesis... which is what I did above.

And based on that exploration, I want to offer a counter-hypothesis: Freud, himself, was sexually abused by his father and his work reached a tipping point where he'd have had to admit the horror of that, but instead he turned his head away from it and flipped the core hypothesis of his entire working model.

What do you think?

I'll close with a note that this essay is not complete. I won't be surprised if I discover later that Freud tackled some of the questions I have posed in later writing–public or private. Freud was a very intelligent man and I haven't read enough of his work to be confident about my rebuttals. And yet the questions above hold. I'm still grateful for Freud's groundbreaking work naming these varied theories, even though it is possible that he might have faltered in some places. Such an original thought artist!

Subscribe by email